|We have precise expectations about how much time Spanish community service learning students spend outside the classroom, but what about the time spent by those teaching the course?|
Recently, an interesting question came up about how much work it is (or isn't) for graduate teaching assistants to teach a Spanish community service learning course.
Here's some background on the concept of "time" in my Spanish in the Community course.
- Students must work 28 hours in the community during the course of the semester.
- 28 hours means that students work in the community 2 hours a week for 14 weeks out of a 15 1/2 week semester
- It is a three-credit course
- The class meets two hours a week
- Two hours of experiential learning equals one hour of classroom learning, according to some sources
- The main grading tasks are three reflective essays and students' community participation self-evaluations
- So, all in all, for three hours of academic credit, students spend two hours a week in class and two hours a week in the community
As the course coordinator, there's no question that I spend that "extra hour" setting up the community partnerships, maintaining those partnerships, responding to just-in-time requests for student volunteers, solving student problems with their community partner, helping lagging students find extra hours, etc. If you've put together one of these courses or taught one, you know what I mean!
But recently the question came up about graduate teaching assistants' time.
One thing is for sure, if our baseline is traditionally-taught, classroom-based course, then we will always have problems conceiving of workload equivalencies with experiential learning courses.
TA feedbackI think it would be a good idea to have feedback about the teaching load from the TAs who have taught SPAN 232.
It's always best to go to the source. I can speculate about how they spend their time, but they know.
What is the "extra" work for TAs in Spanish community service learning courses?
- First and foremost becoming informed about the local immigrant community context, which has to be accomplished through participation and following social media. In Spanish graduate programs, most TAs have little prior knowledge from their other work in the department. (That other work tends to center on the fields of literary analysis, cultural analysis or linguistics.)
- To a lesser extent, learning accurate and complete information about state and federal immigration polices. Again, these are actually rarely known by TAS, but it is easier to find out about them through research.
- At the beginning of the semester, corralling all their students through the process of choosing and signing up for a community partner, which can be surprisingly time-consuming especially for students who fall behind or want a "different" experience.
- Throughout the semester but especially toward the end, working closely with students whose placement is not working out or do not have their necessary hours and who need extra opportunities that must be arranged with community partners.
- Many campuses have a central CSL office that handles the push and pull of placing students with community partners and following up on those. My campus does not.
A possible way to equalize TAs' workIf the goal is to ask TAs to do more work in "Spanish in the Community" in order to even out the workloads among courses, I would suggest requiring a few more hours on TAs' part of direct participation in the community. That would give them a richer understanding of the community and of the students' experiences. I would not want to add more work for students in order to provide more work for TAs.
ConclusionsIn sum, there are some semesters in which everything goes smoothly and the workload is pretty accurately reflected by the syllabus. But there are always semesters in which you have to do a lot of work because students have trouble beginning their work in the community, surprise events happen in the community (e.g., raids, election of an anti-immigrant President!), you need to field requests from community partners for extra volunteer events, or students realize they are behind on their hours (argh).
What are your thoughts about the time required of TAs, instructors, course coordinators, students and community partners in a Spanish community service learning course?